Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

The Problem: Set Out and Explained

Romans 4:1–12

L02-S01

Key Verse

For what saith the scripture? Abraham believed God, and it was counted unto him for righteousness.

Romans 4:3

Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

L02-S02

A. The Problem Stated

Logic Is a Discipline

A field of study: does a statement, or a group of statements, permit us to correctly come to a conclusion?

IMPLY

What a statement does. The truth of A and B carries the truth of C.

INFER

What a person does. We draw out what we believe the statement carries.

An inference is correct only if it matches what was actually implied.

Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

L02-S03

A. The Problem Stated

Some who claim to teach the Bible hold that the Bible upholds irrationality.

01

You cannot reach a correct conclusion the evidence doesn’t warrant.

02

This is where false doctrines come in.

03

The very way the Bible is written demands that we honor logic.

Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

L02-S04

A.3 Irrational Thought in Theology

Two Irrational Claims

Claim a

“If it isn’t stated explicitly in scripture, that gives man the license to come to his own conclusions when it comes to his worship to God.”

The problem: men end up adding to His Word (Deut. 4:2; Rev. 22:18–19). Nadab and Abihu offered fire “which he commanded them not” (Lev. 10:1–2).

Claim b

“Any time human reasoning has to intervene between the Word and a conclusion, the conclusion is human, not divine, and cannot be part of the New Testament pattern.”

The problem: it refutes itself. That claim is itself a conclusion reached by human reasoning.

Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

L02-S05

A.4 Deducing What Is Implied

Paul Reasons From the Text: Romans 4:1–12

01

Abraham was perhaps the greatest example of the patriarchal period.

02

The Jews upheld him as their father, a standard of sorts.

03

Paul uses the point in time Abraham was counted righteous to show circumcision was not its basis.

Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

L02-S06

Board Work

Romans 4:9–11

P1 Abraham believed God; it was counted for righteousness. (Gen. 15:6)

P2 That came before Ishmael’s birth, when Abraham was 86. (Gen. 16:16)

P3 Abraham was circumcised at 99. (Gen. 17:24)

∴ He was counted righteous before circumcision, 13 years or more before.

∴ Circumcision was not the ground of his righteousness. (Rom. 4:10–11)

Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

L02-S07

A.4 Deducing What Is Implied

Explicit Statements, Correct Conclusion

Romans 3:28

Therefore we conclude that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law.

logizomai · to reckon, count, conclude

Abraham’s faith was an obedient faith. (Heb. 11:8; Jas. 2:21)

So the inference that circumcision was needed for righteousness was incorrect.

Doctrine is not a free-for-all, or there would be no false teachers. (2 Pet. 2:1)

“Come now, and let us reason together, saith the LORD.” Isaiah 1:18

Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

L02-S08

B. The Habits of Men

As oft as reason is against a man, so oft will a man be against reason.

Thomas Hobbes, The Elements of Law (1640)

No man wrote the law of rationality, any more than Newton wrote the law of gravity. They described what God built.

Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

L02-S09

B. The Habits of Men

“Like water, many human minds seem to seek the lowest level.” Thomas B. Warren

The Lowest Level

Take the preacher’s word for it.
Keep what we were raised with.
Avoid the discomfort of testing what we hold.

Berea · Acts 17:11

They received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so.

Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

L02-S10

C. Where We Go Next

To tell truth from false doctrine, we must tell valid from invalid, and sound from unsound.

✓ Valid

If the premises are true, the conclusion must be true.

✓ Sound

Valid, and every premise is true. A sound argument proves.

✗ Neither

The conclusion doesn’t follow, or a premise is false.

Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

L02-S11

Discuss

If God had simply said “Do it because I said so,” what would we lose?

Why do you think He reasons with us instead?

Logic & the Bible · Lesson 2

L02-S12

Lesson 2 · Summary

The Bible is written to be understood by reasoning.

01

Logic Is a Discipline

02

Irrationality Breeds Error

03

Paul Reasons From Explicit Statements

04

Men Resist Reason When It Turns on Them

Next: Lesson 3 · Some Crucial Definitions

L02-S13